Kimmy Schmidt and her roommate Titus Andromedon are members of the Columbia House Tape Club and receive their four cassette tape compilation Now That Sounds Like Music. To quote the liner notes, it's, "Music inspired by, but legally different from, the music you love."
One of the artist is Dusk Mountie with their song, “Brother Baptist“. The song is a close enough version of “Sister Christian” by the real life band Night Ranger.
From the "Kimmy Meets a Drunk Lady!" episode (15 Apr. 2016) of the series Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt.